Are we paying too much for athletics?

By Kathleen Weir


“Why should I pay for something I don’t use?”
That was Buffalo State College junior Darcy Wagner’s response to the $96 athletic fee that students are being charged each semester.
“If I was an athlete I wouldn’t mind, but I’m not. That’s $96 that I don’t have and could use for something else,” she said.


In the Fall 2004 semester, the number of undergraduate students enrolled at Buffalo State was 9,008. While not all of those students were enrolled full-time, even the part-time students had to pay $8 per credit hour for the fee. The 2004 athletics budget that was approved was $1,656,400.


Junior Eric Varga said: “It is money that I am required to spend. But since I don’t play sports or go to sporting events it does nothing for me.”

The athletics department Web site states that the fee funds 19 varsity sports and many intramural and club sports. According to associate athletics director for external affairs Tom Koller, there are anywhere from 300 to 350 student-athletes at Buffalo State.


Dr. Gail Maloney, senior associate athletics director and budget manager, said that the fee does not just cover the athletes at Buffalo State. She said that the free fitness center, recreation programs, the fans and spectators that come to watch the sporting events, and many others are considered in the budget and that it would be impossible to calculate those people into an exact number.


Dr. Maloney said that while the teams get funding for their transportation, hotels, equipment, and meals, many of the teams do additional fund-raising for enhanced team experiences. For example: the women’s lacrosse team is planning a trip to Florida during Spring Break and had to fund the trip themselves and the football team recently had a list-a-thon to raise money for some equipment that they want. Dr. Maloney also said that even with the budget increase Buffalo State is only ranked ninth in SUNY athletic fees, and said that comparatively speaking, “that’s not bad.”


When asked what keeps the budget so high, she said that using busses as the main transportation for the teams is the biggest expense, but that it is money well-spent. Vans are cheaper, but not nearly as safe and she believes that safety is of utmost importance.
Dr. Maloney said: “As an administrator I want to look at the parents and say we’re taking care of your sons and daughters as best we can.”
She mentioned that gas prices are going up and that it’s hard to estimate how much each trip is going to cost, but that each trip will cost more each time. In 2004, $134,000 was spent on busses alone.


Although graduate students are not required to pay the athletic fee, they have opinions on it as well. Graduate student Vince Puglia said: “I played undergrad golf at my old college and I can understand why they need the money. Equipment is expensive, not to mention what it costs for teams to travel. We pay the tuition and fees to improve and maintain the school, not just to cater to our own personal needs. I think that the fee is acceptable.”


Graduate student Wendy Sander thinks that it’s ok to have an athletic fee charged to all students, but that “it might be a little high considering that it costs more for the athletic fee that very few students actually use than it does to get an optional parking pass that many students use on a daily basis.”


Dr. Maloney said that to athletes it’s not about the money: “At the end of the day, our athletes play for the love of the game. They just want to wear the orange and black with pride and to represent us as best they can.”


Kathleen Weir can be contacted at Weirka50@buffalostate.edu.

The 2005 Buffalo State College Women’s Softball Team
Photo courtesy of Sports Information